Enjoyed Evergreen lake today -- when it was 30 degrees, frosty white and very cold in Boulder/Erie, it was beautiful, sunny and warmer at Evergreen lake (if just a bit windy).
Skating/ice conditions were better than expected for not being groomed by the Zamboni yet this year (ice is not thick enough). It was definitely solid enough and felt safe, even with sun and 45 degrees. No slush at all. As expected, there are some long continuous cracks throughout the surface that will catch your blade if you don't keep your eyes on what's in front of you (sun reflection definitely helped highlight where they were). We lasted just over an hour skating, felt long enough. Despite the figure skates looking to be in very good shape (maybe even new this year?), our ankles did hurt initially -- I think this is normal unless you skate a lot, so be sure to bring your thickest socks. You can store your shoes/things in wall cubbies (no paid lockers), seemed safe enough, although we used our canvas bags to keep belongings out of sight. No chairs etc. inside, just benches for changing shoes/skates.
We got there about 10:15am, and parking lot was full, but no line at all to get ticket/skates. You can park elsewhere and take their shuttle to the lake. They opened at 9am on a Saturday (as stated on website), but still call the hotline number before showing up, in case of changing weather conditions. Admission + rental was $20. Lots of areas to skate around the smaller (hockey) rinks, never felt crowded, overall it was worth the money.
Just really wish the nice lake house was open for hot chocolate and non-skaters to hang out and relax (I remember that a few years ago - maybe Covid days changed that permanently?). Would make for a more authentic lake experience in the winter! My husband who doesn't skate sat in the car and waited for us - would have been great to have somewhere else to relax in warmth while waiting. Please consider opening the lake house again!